Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
Jake Atonyo photo
1 Level
754 Review
57 Karma

Review on Proto-Pasta - HTPC1705-BRO Proto-Pasta Composite Bronze HTPLA by Jake Atonyo

Revainrating 2 out of 5

The best iron-filled PLA.

I have used 3 spools of this filament in my Lulzbot printers for various projects. The key takeaway is that while at least 3 other competitors are selling metal-filled PLA composites with copper, brass, bronze, etc., there is simply no other competitor (to my knowledge) that offers readily available PLA mixed with iron powder. Luckily, Proto-Pasta's Magnetic Iron PLA is pretty good. In my experience, printing with it can be either easy or impossible, depending on various factors. For me, PLA thermal creep has been an issue with all high-temp proto-pasta PLA filaments, but the iron mix is the worst. I have one printhead that can't really print this filament after a few layers and another that prints it with the default settings just fine. I got a third die head by lowering the retract settings to almost zero and counterintuitively INCREASING the extrusion temperature on the hot end! After printing it looks very good. It bridges well, doesn't stretch too much, hides a bit of layer lines, and has a nice matte texture. Strong magnets can stick to it if you have thick walls and/or dense filling and a strong enough magnet. I'm not sure what the point is. Its weight and ability to rust seem to be its best attributes. Just using a bleach solution sprayed on the printed part and left for a few days can create a very pleasing rust effect. Many tutorials tell you that you can improve the quality of iron PLA parts by grinding and wire brushing them. . However, sanding alters the lightness and texture. So when you do this, sign up for an even and thorough sanding of all the nooks and crannies of the piece. Since in some cases it can be difficult to evenly sand and clean the entire part, I recommend rusting the part without sanding to see if you like the effect. I attached a rocket that I printed with PLA Proto-Pasta irons and had minimal finishing and no sanding as an example.

Pros
  • 3D printing filament
Cons
  • Cable is shorter than others