Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
k edge pro chain catcher black logo

K Edge Pro Chain Catcher Black Review

8

·

Average

Revainrating 3.5 out of 5  
Rating 
3.6
🚴‍♀️ Cycling, 🥋 Sports & Fitness

View on AmazonView on ЯM

Media

(1)
img 1 attached to K Edge Pro Chain Catcher Black

Description of K Edge Pro Chain Catcher Black

Material: aluminum. Compatibility: braze-on. Recommended Use: frame protection, chain catching.

Reviews

Global ratings 8
  • 5
    2
  • 4
    3
  • 3
    1
  • 2
    2
  • 1
    0

Type of review

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Cheap powertrain component insurance

for installation on bike with electronic components. A little more trouble with the mechanics. Definitely worth the price for the trust. The chain only breaks in the worst of times. It's a lot slimmer and sleepier than I thought it would be, which is nice. As with all other reviews, the bolts break easily. I contacted the company and they were very easy to deal with and sent me replacement parts.

Pros
  • Delivery was very quick
Cons
  • Requires Breeze socket

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Easy assembly, peace of mind

After reading here about issues with the 3mm screw that attaches the chain catcher to the bracket, I contacted K-Edge support. They replied that they had already switched providers due to the problem. After ordering, I found it surprisingly easy to install and adjust the derailleur after marking its location. Then I had no problems tightening the screw to 3Nm.

Pros
  • Quality build
Cons
  • A few minor issues

Revainrating 3 out of 5

Good system but hardware is cheap

This is a really great system and relatively easy to install if you don't mind removing and reinstalling the derailleur. The only major issue I had was that the hardware that comes with it is very cheap/boring. It comes off very easily and I'm sure I used the correct size hex wrench because I tried both metric and imperial wrenches until I found one that fit perfectly. Very little torque was required to strip the insulation.

Pros
  • Weight
Cons
  • Long delivery time

Revainrating 2 out of 5

No credit for cheap screws.

Overall design is good but as other reviews have mentioned the iron is too soft. I thought maybe people used the wrong tool or didn't use a torque wrench, but with a torque wrench and a new bit, the bolt comes out well before the packaged torque is reached. A product at this price point shouldn't require a trip to the hardware store to replace cheap screws. Either buy a different brand or plan on going to the store for replacement hardware. Great job K-Edge, you saved pennies on the screw but…

Pros
  • Slim design
Cons
  • Questionable purchase for seniors

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Fits exotic carbon frames

The seat tube on my wife's carbon fiber frame isn't round so the cheaper dog tooth chain catcher won't fit and the gap between the inner chainring and chain is so narrow that if it fell off the chain, it's almost an existential crisis. It just gets stuck so you're afraid of breaking the frame to get it out. It prevents this, which is why I consider it a necessary purchase. I'm glad I have the Pro version which allows you to adjust the derailleur and chain catcher independently. Both parameters…

Pros
  • Great for a small house
Cons
  • Some trouble

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Cheap insurance for expensive frames

I have personally seen a dropped chain scratch the finish on a nice carbon frame as happened to my riding buddy. After that I started using them and now I have them on all four of my family's carbon road bikes. They are nicely made and match the bike, which is what I wanted. The only problem is that the stainless steel set screw is a very soft metal and you can tighten it once in place as the head rounds very easily. I ended up just buying better SS screws from the hardware store to replace…

Pros
  • Great for outdoor activities
Cons
  • Not sure

Revainrating 2 out of 5

Why can't you use better screws

, I just finished my first metric century and had 2 chain drops. I saw this as an important solution so I ordered it and installed it as soon as it was delivered. Installation was easy after watching a few YouTube videos and reading the reviews here. I tried tightening the small screw and it rounded off immediately. Why can't K-Edge find a better screw? Everywhere I see the whole rating and the screw is the weakest link. I went to Lowe's and found a replacement for the .98 and also had to buy…

Pros
  • Everything's great!
Cons
  • Dear

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Very well designed, seems to do the job. Screw head straps easily.

The chain catcher is very well made. It fits my bike perfectly and has perfect clearance for a bottle cage and I can reach it within 0.5mm of the chain when it's in the small ring. I only occasionally drop my chain so I don't know how effective this thing is, but if it protects my shiny new carbon frame I'm happy. My only complaint is that the bolt holding the chain catcher is soft and the head breaks off easily. The instructions recommend a torque of 3-4Nm for this screw, DO NOT tighten to…

Pros
  • So far satisfied
Cons
  • Will write later