They are nice toys, and are probably just fine for gentle or very old dogs. Purchased for a six year old, 60 lb. lab and a 10 year old, 35 lb. border collie (one each) to substitute for stuffed chew toys. Our dogs are not monsters; neither is teething, and we don't play tug of war with our dogs. Our expectation was that these would far outlast plush toys that lasted for a few weeks before they were pulling the stuffing out, and tennis balls that lasted for a few days. The lab had his apart…

Love this toy! Wanted to try this version without the stuffing, as our GSD has a habit of mouthing her toys and pulling the stuffing out. She loves this, the squeakers are sturdy, and no stuffing to tempt her. She carries it around all the time and loves to play with it. So far, no issues, it’s in great shape. And I don’t feel like I have to worry about throwing it in the house, it’s light enough to not damage anything it hits. Definitely recommend this toy!

We have bought these for awhile now, not sure if it is the squeakers as our stuffy ones do not have squeakers. Hope they have not all turned like this.

Lasted about a month with a dog who's a constant chewer. She worried the squeakers out after about the first week and then, continued to work at the toy til there were only a few pieces left and I finally threw it out. The way she goes after toys, I'm surprised it lasted as long as it did.

My daughters dog Revy loves the Tuffy toys! He turned 1yr old and ended up in Vet ER, but is fine now and loving his new toys!

I live this toy judt not for chewers, my little pitty had it chewed up and squeakers out of it in one night, not tuff enough for chewers

My corgi puppy loved the toy, but it lasted only 2.5 months. He first started playing with it when he was barely 4 months old with few teeth and yet he managed to rip it apart in the past month. We found him chewing on one of the squeaky plastic insert today.

I liked there was no stuffing, since I bought it for my lab puppy, a serious chewer! However, he did chew through the binding and remover 2 squeakers. (There may not be a toy strong enough for this dog!)

I got this for my doggy niece and nephew for Christmas. They are both chewers and the toys I got them last Christmas lasted all about 30 seconds! They got all the sruffings out and the squeakers, too. So this year I searched high and low on Revain for toys that would last them a little bit longer. I decided to buy this after reading the many reviews. They still play with this toy and the seams are holding up since Christmas! I am giving it 4 stars because most of the squeakers no longer squeak…

These are awesome. Not indestructible but they last quite a while. We have three Holden retrievers that give them a constant workout. Like that there is no filler. Eventually they chew home and get squeaker out ( we cut out first to extend okay time). I think we get a good 6 mos use maybe more.

This was supposed to be rated a 10 on the Tuff scale, but my bulldog/basset hound mix managed to get two of the four squeakers out in under an hour, and got the other two out the following day. I've had other Tuffy products that were lower-rated on the toughness scale that lasted much longer. I'll probably still buy a stuffed toy occasionally, but the non-stuffed toy seems too easy for my 35-pound dog to rip apart. This product might be okay for dogs who take less joy in destroying things than…

I had heard great things about this toy but was quickly disappointed when my dog ripped a hole in it in less than 5 minutes.

With handles on each end we thought we'd be able to get more than 15 minutes of play time out of the toy before it ripped. Waste of money. If I could rate less than 1 star, I would, but leaving them blank would seem like we weren't offering a rating.

I have a 8 month old Great Pyrenees pup and he ripped a hole and tore a squeaker out within 5 minutes of getting this toy. I thought this ring would last a lot longer considering it has a Tuff rating of 10.

Three generations of Tuffy, about 6 months apart. I have two dogs that love to chew and play tug-of-war and Tuffy keeps them busy! They play with the older versions just as much as the new one. They even snuggle up with their Tuffy.

My pit shreds most squeaky toys in about 15-30 minutes. This is the only only she has not made hardly a mark on in two months. The squeakers all still work. She like to great me with it in her mouth when I come home. So far this is the toughest toy I have found that has squeakers in it.

The dogs love this, but only 4 days and it is a shell with all but one of 4 squeakers torn out. Power chewers will shred this in no time. This shouldn't be marked a 10 tuff rating.

Well I was under the impression that this was a tough ,durable toy. My blue heeler got one of the squeakers out in about 20 minutes. It's still a fun thing for her to carry around but did not make the cut.

It may well be the 'Worlds Toughest Dog Toy', but the squeakers are as cheap as any other dog toy. All were dead after the first hour of use - but the toy itself is still holding up after months of rough use.

My 6 month old puppy really enjoyed playing with this and ate through it within the first day she had it. I have purchased many Tuffy products and they have performed well with the exception of this one. Can not recommend this item to other dog owners. Very disappointed with the poor longevity of the toy.